Check the journal record for a peer-review statement and confirm the article type, because a preprint and a peer-reviewed article can describe the same research but carry different publication status. The steps below use the journal record, the article record, and the deposited metadata together.
-
Identify the journal and the article type. Read the article page for a label such as "preprint," "accepted manuscript," or "research article," and note the journal name. The NIH Preprint Pilot labels eligible life-science preprints in PMC and PubMed as preprints so readers can distinguish publication status. If the record is labeled a preprint, treat it as a preprint and look for a later published version before citing it as peer reviewed.
-
Check the journal record in DOAJ or on the publisher page. DOAJ provides searchable article and journal records for open-access journals that meet its inclusion criteria. Open the journal's record and look for its peer-review statement. On the publisher page, the same information usually sits under "About the journal," "Peer review," or the author guidelines. A journal record that states a peer-review process supports the journal's status; it does not by itself confirm that a specific article went through that process.
-
Confirm the article's status in the deposited metadata. A DOI lookup through the Crossref REST API returns the metadata deposited for that DOI. Use the returned record to confirm the article type and the container (journal) it belongs to, and compare that with what the article page shows. If the metadata and the page disagree, or a field is missing, treat the status as unresolved and check the publisher's article page directly.
-
Decide before citing. Cite the article as peer reviewed when the journal record states a peer-review process and the article record identifies it as a journal article rather than a preprint. Cite it as a preprint when the record carries a preprint label, and search for a published version if your citation requires peer review.
A journal's inclusion in DOAJ reflects its open-access criteria, so use the peer-review statement in the journal record as the relevant detail for this question.
