Home > FAQ > How can I check whether a source in a briefing has been included in a later systematic review?

How can I check whether a source in a briefing has been included in a later systematic review?

October 26, 2026
systematic review inclusion checkincluded studies listevidence synthesis verificationreview database searchsource traceability

Search review databases for the source's topic, then check each review's included-studies list for the source, and read the review's synthesis before relying on the source. This three-step sequence separates two different questions: whether a later review captured the source, and what that review concluded from it.

  1. Search review databases by the source's topic. Use keyword and fielded searches to find systematic reviews on the same topic. Europe PMC supports keyword and fielded searches across life-science literature, including links to available full text, so you can search by topic terms and then open candidate reviews. Record the search terms and date so the check can be repeated.

  2. Open each candidate review's included-studies list. PRISMA 2020 provides a checklist and flow diagrams for transparent reporting of what studies a systematic review found and included. Use that reporting to locate the list of included studies, then look for the source by its identifying details. A match on the included-studies list tells you the review captured the source; a review that does not list it leaves the question unresolved, so check the next review rather than concluding the source was excluded.

  3. Read the review's synthesis before relying on the source. The included-studies list shows capture; the synthesis shows how the review weighed and combined that evidence. Read the synthesis sections that discuss the source's findings so you know whether the review treated them as consistent, conflicting, or limited by study design.

Cochrane guidance on searching for and selecting studies describes planning searches, selecting sources, searching reference lists and other sources, and documenting searches and managing records. Those practices help you keep a traceable record of which reviews you checked and what each one reported.

Use the result to decide whether the briefing should cite the source alone or cite it alongside the later review's synthesis.

←
PreviousHow can I check whether a source in a briefing has been discussed in a later editorial?
NextHow can I check whether a source in a due-diligence memo has been superseded by a newer version?
→