A systems paper is reproducible when another researcher can follow its methodology and achieve similar results using the information provided in the paper. Look for clear descriptions of the experimental setup, publicly available artifacts, and transparent reporting of both successes and limitations.
Check for Complete Experimental Details
Start by examining whether the paper includes all parameters needed to recreate the system. This means specific hardware configurations (CPU, memory, network topology), software versions (OS, libraries, compiler flags), and workload characteristics (dataset sizes, request rates, concurrency levels). Vague statements like "we used a standard configuration" are red flags. The best papers include exact command-line arguments and configuration files.
Assess Artifact Availability
Reproducibility hinges on access to the actual code, datasets, and scripts used in the experiments. Check if the authors provide a public repository (GitHub, Zenodo, or institutional archive) with clear documentation. Papers that only describe algorithms without implementation details are difficult to reproduce. Look for README files that explain how to build, deploy, and run the system with minimal setup friction.
Evaluate Measurement Methodology
Examine how the authors measured performance metrics. Are timing measurements wall-clock time or CPU time? Did they account for warm-up periods and cache effects? How many trials did they run, and are error bars or confidence intervals reported? Systems research is notorious for measurement noise, so papers should explain how they controlled for variability. If a paper only shows best-case results without discussing variance, reproducibility becomes questionable.
Look for Reproducibility Statements
Many top-tier venues now require artifact evaluation badges or reproducibility appendices. These sections explicitly address what artifacts are available and what results can be independently verified. Some papers even include a "reproducibility checklist" that itemizes dependencies and expected outcomes.
Verify Against Independent Replications
Search for follow-up work or technical reports that attempted to reproduce the results. Tools like WisPaper's PaperClaw can help here by parsing the experimental setup from the original PDF and generating a structured reproduction plan with code frameworks and parameter configurations, saving you hours of manual extraction.
When a paper combines detailed methodology, accessible artifacts, transparent measurement practices, and ideally independent validation, you can be reasonably confident in its reproducibility.

