Screen the title and abstract against your predefined inclusion criteria and record an include, exclude, or maybe decision with a stated reason for each record. This is the selection step that Cochrane describes as part of planning searches and selecting studies, and PRISMA 2020 treats transparent reporting of what was found and included as part of review reporting.
A workable screening sequence
- Write your inclusion criteria as short, checkable statements before screening begins, such as population, intervention or exposure, study design, and date range. Expected result: each record can be judged against the same list rather than against a general impression of relevance.
- Read the title and abstract and mark the record include, exclude, or maybe. Expected result: a decision plus a one-line reason, which keeps later reporting consistent.
- For every maybe, retrieve and check the full text before finalizing. Expected result: the maybe resolves to include or exclude on evidence from the full text, not from the abstract alone.
- Keep the reason attached to each exclude decision. Expected result: you can explain why a record was dropped when you report the selection process.
What changes a decision
A record that matches your criteria on title and abstract moves to include or stays at maybe until the full text confirms it. A record that fails a criterion on the abstract can be excluded at that stage. A record whose abstract omits the detail you need, such as the study design or population, is a maybe, and the full text is the next check.
Using search tools to reduce misses
PubMed supports field tags, filters, Advanced Search, and saved searches for locating and refining records, which helps you keep a consistent search while screening. Cochrane also describes searching reference lists and other sources, so a relevant study cited by an included paper is worth checking as a separate record.
Reporting the outcome
PRISMA 2020 provides a checklist and flow diagrams for reporting what studies were found and included. Recording include, exclude, and maybe decisions with reasons as you screen gives you the counts and rationale those reports require.
