Verify a source by locating its DOI, checking the publisher-maintained Crossmark record for that DOI for any retraction or correction notice, and reading the notice details before you finalize the brief. Crossmark provides a way for readers to check a publisher-maintained record for updates such as corrections, retractions, and other changes to a scholarly work.
Step-by-step check
- Find the DOI on the source itself. Use the DOI printed on the article or publisher page instead of a citation copied from another document. ICMJE advises authors to verify references against original sources and to cite direct sources where possible, so confirm the DOI against the original record.
- Open the Crossmark record for that DOI. Crossmark is the publisher-maintained status record for the work. Check whether it lists a retraction, correction, or other update.
- Read the notice itself. COPE's retraction guidance covers the purposes, grounds, notices, and responsibilities involved in correcting the research literature through retraction and related actions. The notice tells you what was retracted, why, and which parts of the record are affected.
- Decide the source's role in the brief. If a retraction notice applies, replace the source or annotate it with the notice details before finalizing. ICMJE advises authors to identify retractions when preparing references, so the brief should make the retraction visible alongside the citation.
- Record the check. Note the DOI, the Crossmark result, and the notice date alongside the citation so a reviewer can repeat the check.
What each result means
- A retraction notice on the Crossmark record: treat the work as retracted and act on step 4.
- A correction or other update: read the notice to see whether the specific claim you rely on is affected.
- No update shown: the record shows no listed change at the time you checked. Record the check date, since publisher records can be updated later.
Boundary
This check covers updates recorded through the publisher's Crossmark record for that DOI. If the DOI is missing or the record cannot be located, the source's status remains unresolved; confirm the DOI against the original publication and check the publisher's page for the article before relying on it.
