Home > FAQ > Should I cite a medical preprint in a manuscript?

Should I cite a medical preprint in a manuscript?

August 20, 2026
medical preprint citationmanuscript writing guidepeer review policyjournal submission rulesresearch integrity

Whether to cite a medical preprint depends on your manuscript's purpose and your journal's policies, but proceed with extreme caution—preprints haven't undergone peer review, which is especially critical in medicine where unverified findings could influence patient care.

When citing preprints may be appropriate

If you're documenting the current state of rapidly evolving research (such as during a disease outbreak) or citing a preprint for its methodology rather than its clinical conclusions, a preprint citation can be justified. Always clearly label it as a preprint in your reference list and acknowledge its non-peer-reviewed status in your text. For example: "Preliminary data from a preprint study (Author et al., 2024, preprint) suggest..."

Risks specific to medical literature

Medical preprints carry higher stakes than other disciplines. Citing unverified treatment protocols, drug efficacy claims, or diagnostic criteria could inadvertently legitimize findings that later prove incorrect or harmful. If a preprint is later retracted or substantially revised after peer review, your citation becomes problematic and potentially misleading to clinicians or policymakers reading your work.

Check journal requirements first

Many medical journals explicitly restrict or prohibit preprint citations. The New England Journal of Medicine and The Lancet have specific guidelines about when preprints are acceptable. Review your target journal's author instructions before submission—some require that preprints be updated to peer-reviewed versions before publication, while others ask you to verify the preprint's current status at proof stage.

Best practices if you must cite

When a preprint is genuinely the only available source for critical information, verify its claims independently through other literature or data sources. WisPaper's TrueCite automatically checks citation formatting and helps track whether preprints have since been published in peer-reviewed journals, reducing the risk of citing outdated versions. Include the preprint server name (bioRxiv, medRxiv), DOI, and access date in your reference.

The safest approach: wait for peer-reviewed publication whenever possible, especially for claims that directly inform clinical practice or public health policy.

Should I cite a medical preprint in a manuscript?
←
PreviousHow can I use MeSH terms to improve a PubMed literature search?
NextWhat should I do when animal study evidence conflicts with clinical evidence?
→