Can printing money NOT raise inflation?

Why the same money printing can have different effects

The effect of money printing on inflation is not fixed; it depends on the state of the economy. In South Africa, researchers found that a 1% increase in money supply was associated with a 0.05% decrease in inflation in one economic state and a 0.35% increase in another [1]. This means that in some periods, money growth did not raise inflation—and even coincided with slightly lower inflation—while in other periods it did raise inflation.

The study also found that the economy spent more than five years in each state, and the probability of moving between states was significant [1]. So the state is not a brief anomaly; it can persist for years. This helps explain why someone might observe a period where printing money did not raise inflation and conclude that it never does.

The inflation may arrive later than the money printing

Even when money printing does raise inflation, the effect may not be immediate. In Switzerland, broad money excesses over trend values were followed by persistently higher inflation and output after the usual monetary policy transmission lags [2]. The word 'followed' is important: the inflation came after the money growth, not at the same time.

This delay can create the illusion that printing money does not raise inflation, especially if you only look at the months right after the money is created. The Swiss study covered data since the mid-1970s and found that money and exchange rate fluctuations could explain the major inflation developments over four decades [2]. That is a long-run relationship, not a same-day effect.

When money printing is extreme, inflation can become hyperinflation

The historical record shows that sustained and extreme money printing can lead to hyperinflation. In World War I Germany, the government printed Reichsbank notes so intensively that, in the last year of the hyperinflation, bank notes were produced with less ink and time to keep up [3]. That is a case where printing money clearly did raise inflation—to an extreme degree.

This does not mean every money printing episode leads to hyperinflation. The German case involved a specific historical context of war, fiscal pressure, and extreme money creation [3]. But it does show that the idea 'printing money never raises inflation' cannot be true in general.

In developing economies, the link may be different

Some researchers argue that the dynamics of inflation in developing economies are different enough that the idea 'inflation is always a monetary phenomenon' needs to be revisited [4]. In Nepal, a study found that the Consumer Price Index was positively related to economic growth, suggesting that inflation and growth can move together in ways that complicate the simple story [4].

However, that study did not test whether printing money fails to cause inflation; it focused on how money supply and inflation affect economic growth [4]. So it does not provide direct evidence that money printing can avoid inflation. It does suggest that the relationship between money, prices, and growth may be more complex in developing countries than in the Swiss or South African contexts.

Sources used in this answer

Related research questions