How has telemedicine been used in surgical and anesthetic care across urban and rural settings?

A scoping review of 98 studies finds telemedicine most used for postoperative follow-up and specialist consultation.

Direct answer

Across 98 studies from the United States, Canada, and Australia published between 1992 and 2024, telemedicine in surgical and anesthetic care was used most often for postoperative follow-up (60.2%), specialist consultation (42.9%), and preoperative screening (34.7%). Rural-framed studies (39.8%) leaned on video and access-focused uses such as specialist consultation and preoperative triage, while non-rural studies more often emphasized telephone, app-based, and efficiency-oriented models. The review reports similar short-term clinical outcomes and high patient satisfaction, but formal cost and equity evidence remains thin.

1sources cited

This article was generated with WisPaper-powered search and paper analysis.

A map of 98 studies, not a pooled effect

This is a scoping review, which means the authors set out to chart what has been studied, where, and how, rather than to pool results into a single estimate of benefit. They followed JBI methodology and PRISMA-ScR guidance, screened 9,923 titles and abstracts after removing 5,312 duplicates, and reviewed 181 full texts. Of those, 83 were excluded, most often for an ineligible design (22 of 83), for not involving telemedicine in surgical or anesthetic care (13 of 83), or for focusing on geographies outside the three target countries (12 of 83). The final synthesis covers 98 studies.

That design choice shapes how the findings should be read. When the paper says telemedicine was "frequently reported" to have outcomes similar to in-person care, it is summarizing what individual studies concluded, not reporting a combined effect size. The authors themselves note that most studies were not designed as formal non-inferiority trials, so the similarity is a recurring observation across heterogeneous studies rather than a tested equivalence claim.

Output concentrated in the United States after 2020

Publication years ran from 1992 to 2024, but only one study predated 2005, and 60 of the 98 studies (61.2%) appeared from 2020 onward. The geographic balance shifted with that growth. Before 2020, 18 of 38 studies (47.4%) were from the United States, 10 (26.3%) from Canada, and 10 (26.3%) from Australia. From 2020 onward, 42 of 60 studies (70.0%) were United States-focused, versus 11 (18.3%) from Canada and 7 (11.7%) from Australia.

The authors connect this surge to the COVID-19 pandemic, describing a shift toward feasibility, utilization, and service delivery as health systems sought ways to maintain surgical continuity when in-person capacity was constrained. That interpretation matters for readers comparing eras: the post-2020 literature is larger but also differently motivated, with cost-effectiveness as a primary topic in only 7 of 60 studies (11.7%), compared with 15 of 38 (39.5%) before 2020.

Follow-up dominates, anesthesia stays marginal

Telemedicine interventions spanned the perioperative pathway, but the weight was uneven. Postoperative follow-up appeared in 59 of 98 studies (60.2%), typically comparing telephone or video visits with in-person clinic visits after joint arthroplasty, spine surgery, neurosurgical operations, vascular interventions, and pediatric urological or general surgery. Preoperative screening or assessment appeared in 34 studies (34.7%), used for history-taking, consent discussions, medication review, and in some cases basic physical examination supported by local clinicians. Remote patient monitoring appeared in 15 studies (15.3%).

Anesthesia-specific telemedicine was rare: 4 of 98 studies (4.1%). Anesthesiologists were named as telemedicine providers in those same 4 studies, compared with surgeons in 76 (77.6%). The authors flag this as a gap, noting that pre-anesthetic assessment is central to perioperative safety and that virtual preoperative clinics have been reported as feasible. Their proposed next step is to define which elements of pre-anesthetic assessment can be done remotely, for which patients, and with what local support.

Rural programs used video to reach specialists

A rural or remote focus was explicit in 39 of 98 studies (39.8%), and these were proportionally most common in Australia (10 of 17, 58.8%), followed by Canada (9 of 21, 42.9%) and the United States (20 of 60, 33.3%). The design of rural-framed programs differed from non-rural ones in ways that suggest different purposes. Video conferencing was used in 28 of 39 rural-framed studies (71.8%) versus 25 of 59 non-rural-framed studies (42.4%). Preoperative screening appeared in 17 of 39 rural-framed studies (43.6%) versus 17 of 59 non-rural (28.8%), and specialist consultation in 23 of 39 (59.0%) versus 19 of 59 (32.2%).

The authors read this pattern as telemedicine serving different functions by context: in rural and remote settings it addressed geographic access to scarce specialist services, while in urban settings it more often addressed convenience and operational efficiency. That is the authors' interpretation of the distribution, not a tested causal claim. The measured differences are in study design and application mix, and the review did not compare patient outcomes between rural and urban programs directly.

Short-term safety looks similar, costs stay descriptive

Across studies, telemedicine was frequently reported to have similar short-term clinical outcomes to in-person care, including complications, emergency department and urgent care visits, readmissions, and reoperations. Several randomized trials and controlled cohort studies reported no significant differences on these endpoints. Patient satisfaction was generally high, with several studies reporting comparable or higher satisfaction than in-person care, though some patients preferred in-person visits and cited technical difficulties, access barriers, and the absence of physical examination.

Cost evidence is much weaker than the outcome evidence. Many studies quantified distance traveled, travel time, missed work or school, and avoided accommodation, meals, or parking expenses, and some rural models described substantial cumulative reductions. But only two studies were coded as formal economic evaluations, and few incorporated infrastructure, staffing, technology support, reimbursement, downstream health-system utilization, or societal costs. The authors describe the economic analyses as largely descriptive, which means the travel savings reported should not be read as a full cost-effectiveness verdict.

Equity was named more often than measured

Rurality was frequently addressed, and several studies examined travel distance and regional access. Other equity dimensions were not. Few studies measured outcomes stratified by digital literacy, digital access, English proficiency, or other demographic characteristics, and most did not report interpreter needs. Qualitative findings commonly identified these factors as perceived barriers, but the review found little quantitative evaluation of them.

This leaves an open question the authors state directly: it remains unclear whether telemedicine narrows or widens surgical access gaps for different populations. That uncertainty sits alongside the favorable access findings, and it qualifies them. A program that reduces travel for patients who can use video may still exclude patients who lack devices, connectivity, or language support, and the reviewed literature largely does not measure that exclusion.

Where the next evidence needs to land

The review's most decision-relevant split is between what has been well described and what has been tested. Utilization (70 of 98 studies, 71.4%) and feasibility or acceptability (49 of 98, 50.0%) were the most common research topics, while access and epidemiologic or outcome metrics were coded in 26 studies each (26.5%) and cost-effectiveness in 22 (22.4%). The authors call for more rigorous comparative studies across diverse settings and populations, economic evaluations that go beyond travel-cost estimates, and routine reporting of digital access measures and outcomes stratified by patient demographics.

For readers weighing telemedicine in a perioperative pathway, the paper's own variables point to a specific priority: the choice between video and telephone, and between access-oriented and efficiency-oriented models, tracks the rural or urban framing of the program rather than a single best practice. The evidence supports comparable short-term outcomes and high satisfaction for selected perioperative indications, especially postoperative follow-up, but it does not yet establish which patients should be selected for virtual versus in-person care, how longer-term recovery and quality of life are affected, or whether access gains reach the patients who need them most.

Sources used in this answer

1

Telemedicine in surgical and anesthetic care in urban and rural settings across time: a scoping review

Across 98 studies from the US, Canada, and Australia (1992–2024), telemedicine was most used for postoperative follow-up (60.2%), specialist consultation (42.9%), and preoperative screening (34.7%); rural-framed studies (39.8%) favored video and access-focused uses, and short-term outcomes were frequently reported as similar to in-person care.