Home > FAQ > Guideline rests on possibly retracted study: check Crossmark or search PubMed for retraction notice?

Guideline rests on possibly retracted study: check Crossmark or search PubMed for retraction notice?

October 26, 2026
retraction notice checkingCrossmark DOI recordPubMed literature verificationguideline evidence appraisalretracted study detection

Checking Crossmark and searching PubMed answer different questions: Crossmark shows whether the publisher has recorded an update such as a correction or retraction for that specific DOI, while a PubMed search locates retraction notices and related records indexed in PubMed, so use both in sequence. Each check draws on a different record source, and together they cover the publisher's update record and the biomedical literature index.

Step 1: Identify the study behind the recommendation. Read the guideline's reference list and confirm which cited study supports the specific recommendation you plan to rely on. Expected result: a citation with a DOI you can check.

Step 2: Check the Crossmark record for that DOI. Crossmark provides a way for readers to check a publisher-maintained record for updates such as corrections, retractions, and other changes to a scholarly work. Expected result: the publisher's record either shows an update status or shows none.

Step 3: Search PubMed for a retraction notice. PubMed supports field tags, phrase searching, filters, Advanced Search, citation matching, similar-article links, and saved searches for locating and refining biomedical records. Use these tools to find the study record and any linked retraction notice. Expected result: either a retraction notice tied to the study or no notice found in PubMed.

Step 4: Interpret the combined result. COPE's retraction guidance describes purposes, grounds, notices, and responsibilities for correcting the research literature through retraction and related actions, which helps you read a notice once you find one. If either check surfaces a retraction, do not rely on the recommendation without finding replacement evidence. If neither check surfaces an update, the status remains unresolved; record what you checked and when.

Step 5: Act on a retracted study. Treat the recommendation as unsupported by that study and look for other evidence the guideline cites for the same recommendation before using it in research or evidence synthesis.

←
PreviousDataCite or repository page: which identifies a dataset version?
NextHow can I check that each cited trial's registered eligibility criteria match its paper?
→