Home > FAQ > How can I check that each cited trial's registered eligibility criteria match its paper?

How can I check that each cited trial's registered eligibility criteria match its paper?

October 26, 2026
trial eligibility verificationregistration record auditsystematic review screeningmethods section comparisonevidence synthesis quality control

Build a fixed audit table, compare each trial's structured eligibility fields on its registration record with the eligibility criteria in the paper's methods section, and escalate every mismatch to the synthesis lead with both sources quoted. ClinicalTrials.gov defines structured registration fields for eligibility alongside study identification, design, locations, and outcomes, so the record gives you a stable field to compare against the paper text.

Set up the check

  1. Create one audit row per cited trial with columns for trial identifier, registration record eligibility text, paper methods eligibility text, match or mismatch, the quoted text from each source, and reviewer initials. Expected result: every cited trial has a row and no trial is skipped.
  2. Locate the registration record for each trial and copy its eligibility field verbatim into the row. ClinicalTrials.gov search lets you filter records by condition, intervention, location, status, study type, and dates, which helps confirm you have the intended record. Expected result: each row holds the exact registered wording.
  3. Copy the eligibility criteria from the paper's methods section verbatim into the same row. Expected result: both texts sit side by side for direct comparison.
  4. Compare the two texts criterion by criterion, such as age limits, sex, diagnosis, prior treatment, and comorbidity exclusions, and mark each row as match or mismatch. Expected result: a completed audit table with quoted evidence for each judgment.
  5. Repeat the same fields and comparison rules for every trial so later reviewers apply an identical check. Expected result: a table another reviewer can re-run without redefining the method.

Handle mismatches

Escalate each mismatch to the synthesis lead with both quoted passages attached, so the team can decide whether to qualify or exclude the trial. Record that decision and its rationale in the audit row so the synthesis carries a traceable record. Cochrane Handbook guidance on selecting studies and managing records supports documenting selection decisions and keeping the search and selection process transparent.

Keep the audit reproducible

Store the completed table with the review files and note the date each record was checked, since registration records can be updated. PubMed field tags, filters, and saved searches can help you relocate the paper records when you need to re-verify a row.

←
PreviousGuideline rests on possibly retracted study: check Crossmark or search PubMed for retraction notice?
NextHow can I check whether a clinical guideline's recommendation is based on a retracted study?
→