Home > FAQ > How can I check whether a clinical guideline's recommendation is based on a retracted study?

How can I check whether a clinical guideline's recommendation is based on a retracted study?

October 26, 2026
retracted study checkclinical guideline appraisalCrossmark DOI lookupreference verificationevidence synthesis

You can check by tracing the specific study cited for the recommendation, then looking up that study's DOI in the publisher-maintained Crossmark record to see whether a retraction notice has been posted. Crossmark provides a way for readers to check a publisher-maintained record for updates such as corrections, retractions, and other changes to a scholarly work. COPE's retraction guidance describes purposes, grounds, notices, and responsibilities for correcting the research literature through retraction and related actions, so a retraction notice is the document that signals the study has been corrected out of the literature.

Step-by-step check

  1. Locate the exact citation behind the recommendation. Open the guideline section that states the recommendation and find the reference number or citation attached to that specific claim. Guidelines often cite several studies for one recommendation, so identify which one supports the statement you plan to rely on.
  2. Retrieve the cited study and its DOI. Open the original article through the publisher or a DOI resolver and copy the DOI printed on the article record. Confirm the title, authors, and year match the guideline's reference, since a mismatch means you are looking at a different paper.
  3. Check the Crossmark record for that DOI. Use the Crossmark link on the publisher's article page to view the publisher-maintained record. Look for an update status such as a correction, retraction, or other change. A retraction notice in that record tells you the study has been retracted.
  4. Read the retraction notice itself. COPE guidance covers the notice as the formal record of why the literature is being corrected. Read the stated reason and the date to judge whether the finding the guideline relied on is affected.
  5. Record the retraction before relying on the recommendation. Note the retracted study, the recommendation it supports, and the retraction date in your evidence table or appraisal notes. This keeps the retraction visible when you use the guideline in synthesis.

What the check tells you

ICMJE advises authors to verify references against original sources, cite direct sources where possible, and identify retractions. That makes the citation-to-DOI-to-Crossmark path a reference-verification task: you confirm the guideline's cited source and its current publication status. If the Crossmark record shows no update, the study's status is unchanged in that record; if it shows a retraction, treat the recommendation as resting on a retracted study and flag it in your appraisal.

←
PreviousHow can I check that each cited trial's registered eligibility criteria match its paper?
NextHow can I check whether a clinical trial I want to cite was actually registered?
→