Search review databases for meta-analyses on the paper's topic, then check each meta-analysis's included-studies list for the paper, and read the pooled estimate before relying on the paper's findings. This sequence separates two questions that are easy to conflate: whether the paper was eligible for a synthesis, and what that synthesis concluded.
- Search review databases by topic. Run keyword and fielded searches on the paper's topic in review-focused databases. Europe PMC supports keyword and fielded searches across life-science literature, including links to available full text, so you can search by topic terms and then open candidate reviews. Record the search terms and sources you used, as the Cochrane Handbook recommends documenting searches for systematic reviews.
- Confirm the review is a meta-analysis. A systematic review may report included studies without pooling results. Check the methods and results for a pooled estimate; if none is reported, the included-studies list still tells you whether the paper was captured, but there is no pooled result to read.
- Open the included-studies list. PRISMA 2020 provides a checklist and flow diagrams for reporting what studies were found and included, so a review following it should show which studies entered the synthesis. Search the list for the paper's authors, year, and study design. If the paper appears, note which outcome and comparison it contributed to.
- Read the pooled estimate before relying on the paper. Locate the pooled effect for the outcome you care about, along with the studies contributing to it. The pooled result, not the single paper, is what the synthesis reports for that outcome.
- Handle a missing paper as unresolved. If the paper is absent from the list, check whether the review's eligibility criteria, search date, or outcome definitions would have excluded it. Absence from one review does not establish that the paper was overlooked; search for other reviews on the same topic and compare their included-studies lists.
As a practical check, compare the review's search date with the paper's publication date. A review whose searches closed before the paper appeared could not have included it, and a newer review may be the better place to look.
