Home > FAQ > How can I check whether a paper's findings have been replicated?

How can I check whether a paper's findings have been replicated?

October 26, 2026
replication checkcited-by searchcitation trackingabstract screeningevidence verification

You can check whether a paper's findings have been replicated by following its cited-by links to later papers, screening titles and abstracts for replication language, and recording the replication's outcome and sample before you rely on the original. Google Scholar documents cited-by links as a way to see work that cites a given paper, and Semantic Scholar's Academic Graph API provides citation data you can query for the same purpose.

Step-by-step check

  1. Open the original paper's cited-by list. In Google Scholar, use the cited-by link on the paper's record; through the Semantic Scholar API, retrieve the paper's citations. Expected result: a list of later papers that reference the original.
  2. Sort or filter toward later work. Google Scholar documents date sorting, which helps you move past early commentary to studies published after the original. Expected result: a shorter list weighted toward follow-up studies.
  3. Screen titles and abstracts for replication language. Look for terms such as "replication," "reproduce," "failed to replicate," or "direct replication." Expected result: a shortlist of candidate replication studies, with general citations set aside.
  4. Read the replication's outcome and sample. Note whether the replication reports a consistent or inconsistent result and what sample it used. Expected result: a decision on whether the replication bears on the original finding for your context.
  5. Widen the search if the cited-by list is thin. The Cochrane Handbook describes searching reference lists and other sources and documenting the search. Expected result: a documented trail you can describe in your manuscript or review.

What changes your decision

A replication with a different sample or population may not test the same claim as the original, so match the replication's sample to the population your manuscript addresses. A citation that mentions the original without reporting a replication attempt does not establish replication; treat it as unresolved and check the citing paper's methods. If no replication appears in the cited-by list, the status remains unresolved rather than disproven, and the next step is to search the topic directly and check reference lists of relevant reviews.

←
PreviousHow can I check whether a paper's findings have been included in a meta-analysis?
NextHow can I check whether a paper's reference list cites a retracted study without noticing?
→