You can check a reference list for retracted studies by extracting each reference's DOI and looking up its publisher-maintained Crossmark record for a retraction notice, then replacing any flagged reference before resubmission. The ICMJE Recommendations support this practice: they advise authors to verify references against original sources and to identify retractions.
Step-by-step check
- Extract the DOI for each reference. Work through the list entry by entry and record the DOI where one is given. References without a DOI need a separate lookup to find the identifier before you can check their status.
- Open the Crossmark record for each DOI. Crossmark provides a way for readers to check a publisher-maintained record for updates such as corrections, retractions, and other changes to a scholarly work. Read the record's status field for any retraction notice.
- Flag every reference with a retraction notice. Mark it in the manuscript and note what the notice says, since a retraction notice describes the grounds and purpose of the correction to the literature under COPE's retraction guidance.
- Replace flagged references before resubmission. Remove the retracted citation or substitute a sound source, then recheck the replacement's DOI the same way.
- Record the outcome. Keep a short log of DOIs checked and any notices found so you can show the verification step was done.
What the check can and cannot settle
A Crossmark record reflects the update status maintained by the publisher of that work. If a DOI has no Crossmark record, or the record shows no update, that result does not by itself confirm the study is sound; treat it as unresolved and verify the reference against the original source, as the ICMJE advises. Where a retraction notice exists, follow the notice's stated grounds when deciding whether to remove the citation or discuss it explicitly.
Practical notes
- Check the version of record, not a preprint or secondary citation, since Crossmark attaches to the publisher-maintained record.
- Recheck references added late in revision; a reference list edited after the first pass needs the same DOI check.
- Cite direct sources where possible, per ICMJE guidance, which reduces the chance of inheriting a retracted claim through a secondary citation.
