You can catch a retracted reference by extracting each DOI from the reference list and checking the publisher-maintained Crossmark record for a retraction notice, then flagging and replacing any retracted item before you rely on the paper. Crossmark gives readers a way to check a publisher-maintained record for updates such as corrections, retractions, and other changes to a scholarly work. ICMJE also advises authors to verify references against original sources, cite direct sources where possible, and identify retractions.
Step-by-step check
- Extract the identifiers. Pull each DOI from the reference list into a working list. Keep the citation text beside each DOI so you can match a notice back to the exact reference.
- Open the Crossmark record for each DOI. Look for the publisher-maintained status and any listed updates. A record showing a retraction notice is your flag; a record with no listed update is unresolved until you confirm the reference matches the DOI.
- Confirm the notice matches the cited work. Check that the retraction notice refers to the same article you are citing, not a different paper by the same authors or a related correction.
- Flag and replace. Mark every retracted reference in the manuscript and replace it with a current source that supports the same claim, or revise the claim if no replacement supports it.
- Re-check the replacement. Run the new reference through the same DOI and Crossmark check before finalizing.
Where this matters most
A reference list can carry a retracted study silently because the citation text itself rarely changes after publication. The retraction lives in the publisher's record, so the DOI check is what surfaces it. COPE's retraction guidance describes retraction and related notices as the mechanism for correcting the research literature, which is why the notice, not the original citation, is the signal to look for.
Practical boundaries
- A DOI that does not resolve, or a record with no update listed, does not by itself prove the reference is valid. Treat it as unresolved and verify the citation against the original source, as ICMJE recommends.
- References without DOIs need a manual check against the publisher's page for the article.
- Run this pass on the final reference list, since references added late in drafting are the easiest to leave unchecked.
