Checking a manuscript against a reporting guideline is the difference between a draft that reads well and a submission that can be evaluated. Journal editors and peer reviewers increasingly expect authors to attach a completed checklist and point to where each required item appears. The practical task is therefore not just to read the guideline, but to map your manuscript item by item, locate gaps, fix them, and produce evidence of completion.
This guide walks through that sequence for one concrete combination: a systematic review being prepared against the PRISMA 2020 checklist, which contains 27 items plus an abstract checklist and flow diagrams. The same workflow applies to other study types once you select the matching guideline from the EQUATOR Network database.
Where do you start when the manuscript is already written?
Most writers check a guideline after the draft exists, not before. Start by identifying the exact guideline that matches your study design. The EQUATOR Network organizes reporting guidelines by study type and specialty so authors can choose a checklist that matches the design they are reporting. If you are preparing a systematic review, select PRISMA 2020. If the work is a randomized trial, a diagnostic accuracy study, or a qualitative study, choose the corresponding checklist rather than forcing PRISMA onto the wrong design.
Once the checklist is identified, open the full guidance document, not only the short checklist. PRISMA 2020 provides a 27-item checklist, expanded explanations, an abstract checklist, and flow diagrams for transparent reporting of systematic reviews. The expanded explanations matter because they define what counts as adequate for each item.
Create a mapping table before you read your manuscript closely. List every item number in the first column, the manuscript section where you believe it is addressed in the second, and a status marker such as "reported," "partially reported," or "missing" in the third. This table becomes both your diagnostic and your submission artifact, because many journals ask you to state the page or line number where each checklist item appears.
Before mapping, organize the reviewed papers in your WisPaper library so that every cited study is easy to locate during the check. Save and organize your papers in WisPaper's library at the point you begin evidence checking, before the guideline mapping starts.
How do you locate the gap between the guideline and the draft?
Work item by item, not section by section. The temptation is to read the manuscript from introduction to discussion and tick items as you encounter them. That approach misses items that should appear in one place but are currently fragmented or absent. A checklist-led pass catches those.
For each PRISMA item, ask two questions. First, does the required information appear? Second, does it appear where the guideline and a reader would expect it? A review may describe its search strategy in the methods, but PRISMA items 6 and 7 require specific elements: the information sources searched, the search date or period, and the full search strategy for at least one database. A sentence saying "we searched PubMed and Embase" is partial, not complete.
Mark each row with one of the three statuses. Do not soften "missing" to "implicit." If the reader cannot point to a sentence, the item is missing for checklist purposes. The mapping table tells you exactly what to fix before submission.
What does a worked example look like?
Consider a systematic review of early mobilization after hip fracture surgery in adults aged 65 and older. The population is older adults with hip fracture; the intervention is early mobilization protocols; the comparison is usual or delayed mobilization; the primary outcome is length of hospital stay, with functional recovery at three months as a secondary outcome.
Run a PRISMA 2020 pass across this draft and the mapping table begins to fill in:
| PRISMA item | Manuscript section | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Item 3: rationale | Introduction, final paragraph | Reported |
| Item 4: objectives | Introduction, final paragraph | Reported |
| Item 5: eligibility criteria | Methods, study selection | Reported |
| Item 6: information sources | Methods, search strategy | Partially reported |
| Item 7: search strategy | Methods, search strategy | Partially reported |
| Item 8: selection process | Methods, study selection | Reported |
| Item 9: data collection process | Methods, data extraction | Missing |
| Item 10: data items | Methods, outcomes | Reported |
| Item 11: risk of bias | Methods, quality assessment | Partially reported |
| Item 13: study selection flow | Results | Partially reported |
| Item 22: certainty of evidence | Discussion | Missing |
Two patterns emerge. First, methodological items are more likely to be partial or missing than objective and eligibility items, because authors summarize what they did without the operational detail the checklist requires. Second, items that live in results and discussion are forgotten when the abstract and methods were drafted carefully. The mapping table turns a vague feeling that the manuscript is incomplete into a fix list.
If the checklist shows your search missed a database or a newly published trial, search WisPaper for academic papers to close the evidence gap before revising the methods.
How do you fix the gaps without rewriting the whole paper?
Address the missing and partial rows in order of reader impact, starting with the items reviewers check first.
For the worked example, item 6 is partial because the draft says "PubMed and Embase were searched" but leaves out search dates and any registries or reference lists. Repair by adding the date each source was last searched and listing supplementary sources such as trial registries. Item 7 requires the full search strategy for at least one database, including filters and limits; paste the PubMed strategy into a supplementary file and state in the methods that it is available there.
Item 9 asks how many reviewers screened and extracted, whether they worked independently, and how disagreements were resolved. Add one paragraph describing duplicate screening, a pilot extraction form, and consensus or third-reviewer resolution.
Item 11 is partial if the draft names a tool but does not say how judgments were applied to each outcome. State which tool was used, which reviewers rated, and how risk-of-bias findings informed the synthesis and interpretation.
Item 13 requires a flow diagram showing records identified, duplicates removed, records screened, full texts assessed, studies included, and reasons for exclusion at the full-text stage. Generate the PRISMA flow diagram with your actual numbers and reference it in the results.
Item 22 belongs in the discussion. For each main outcome, state the certainty or strength of the evidence and the main factors that lowered or raised it, such as risk of bias, inconsistency, imprecision, or indirectness. For the mobilization review, note that length of stay was reported consistently but from studies with moderate risk of bias, while functional recovery at three months was measured with different instruments, introducing indirectness.
How do you verify the corrected draft?
After edits, run a second checklist pass. This time, record the page or line number for each item rather than only the section. The page numbers are what journals request when they ask authors to state where each checklist item is addressed. If any row still lacks a precise location, the item is not yet adequately reported.
A useful verification method is fresh-reader triangulation. Ask a colleague who was not involved in writing to take the checklist, locate each item in the manuscript, and mark it independently. Disagreements between your mapping and theirs identify places where the information exists but is not discoverable. Rewrite those sentences for explicitness.
Store the checklist and the completed mapping table alongside the manuscript in your project workspace. When a research team manages several guidelines across reviews, keeping each checklist with its manuscript prevents the common failure of attaching the prior submission's file to the current one.
Create a Research Project in WisPaper for the guideline-check stage so the manuscript, checklist, corrected flow diagram, and verification notes stay together during revision.
How does your reference library support the checklist work?
A reporting guideline check depends on having the guideline, the manuscript, and the cited studies in one place. Save the full PRISMA 2020 document and the EQUATOR entry you used to your library so the version you checked is preserved. Organize papers in your WisPaper library at the point you begin evidence checking, before the guideline mapping starts. When the manuscript cites a study whose contribution to a checklist item is unclear, you can ask targeted questions about the papers already in your library rather than searching from scratch for what the citation supports.
For rapid questions about a specific claim, ask questions based on your WisPaper library or papers added from search results. This helps when a reviewer question lands after submission and you need to confirm whether a cited paper matches the PICO you stated in item 5.
If you notice during the checklist pass that several citations in the reference list do not match the screening decisions, run the BibTeX through TrueCite, which checks BibTeX against real academic databases to flag hallucinated references. That step protects the integrity of the flow diagram and the eligibility counts.
When should you run the checklist in the writing process?
Three checkpoints produce the most value. Run a diagnostic pass after the first complete draft, before asking co-authors for detailed feedback. The mapping table gives co-authors a concrete agenda rather than a request for general comments.
Run a verification pass after revisions are merged, when you record page numbers. Then run a final readiness pass after formatting, because journal-specific formatting can push content between sections and invalidate the page numbers you listed. ICMJE guidance tells authors to follow the selected journal's current instructions for article type, format, required statements, and submission materials, so the final pass should confirm that the checklist and the formatted manuscript still agree.
The guideline check is not a once-per-version activity. Any change that moves a sentence between sections requires rechecking the page mapping.
What does a reusable completion checklist look like?
Use this checklist at the final readiness pass. It is written for PRISMA 2020 but adapts to any guideline by replacing the item count:
- The correct guideline for the study design was selected from the EQUATOR Network database.
- The full guidance document, not only the short checklist, was reviewed.
- Every item has a status of reported, partially reported, or missing.
- Every partial or missing item was fixed and re-verified.
- A page or line number is recorded for every item in the final formatted manuscript.
- The PRISMA flow diagram uses the actual study counts and matches the results text.
- The abstract checklist is completed and consistent with the main text.
- Certainty of evidence is discussed for each main outcome.
- A second reader independently located each item in the manuscript.
- The completed checklist and mapping table are saved with the submission files.
A manuscript is ready when all ten boxes are checked. The most defensible signals are the second reader's independent mapping and the presence of a precise page number for every item.
How do you connect this to a broader research workflow?
A guideline check is a project milestone, not an isolated chore. If your team maintains several manuscripts under review, create a Research Project in WisPaper for the guideline-check stage. The project area becomes the place where the manuscript, the completed checklist, the corrected flow diagram, and the verification notes live together during revision.
For systematic reviews that start from a broad topic, the checklist often reveals that a background search was insufficient. Use WisPaper search to find academic papers missing from your sources when items 6 and 7 show the search strategy overlooked a relevant database or a newly published trial. This closes the loop between reporting quality and evidence completeness.
For larger literature tasks that feed a systematic review or research synthesis, the Scholar Agent area supports longer research workflows around literature review and related use cases. A PRISMA check sometimes exposes that the underlying search was too narrow, and extending the evidence base is the substantive fix rather than a wording change.




